Two Decades of Financial Recruitment and 8 and half with my name above the door – what have we learnt?
Eight and a half years into launching Gifford and Partners, and after more than 20 years working across the accounting and finance recruitment market, there are certain things I have become increasingly convinced about. Some things have changed enormously. Others really haven’t. 1. Recruitment markets are cyclical. Timing matters. Markets move in cycles and timing […]
Eight and a half years into launching Gifford and Partners, and after more than 20 years working across the accounting and finance recruitment market, there are certain things I have become increasingly convinced about.
Some things have changed enormously.
Others really haven’t.
1. Recruitment markets are cyclical. Timing matters.
Markets move in cycles and timing can have a significant impact on your success, whether you’re a candidate considering your next move or a business looking to appoint.
For clients, if you have the luxury of choosing when to take a vacancy to market, think carefully about when you land that punch.
There are periods when candidate availability is stronger, periods when competition for talent increases and periods when seemingly everyone decides to recruit at once.
For candidates, the same principle applies.
Jumping into the market at the right point can make a considerable difference to the opportunities available, the competition you face and ultimately the choices you have.
Timing isn’t everything in recruitment, but it can certainly stack the odds in your favour.
2. Being reactive can leave you behind the market
The recruitment market has shifted.
As a candidate, waiting for the perfect advert to appear and then applying can mean you are already on the back foot.
By the time a vacancy reaches LinkedIn or a job board, conversations may already be taking place, recruiters may have approached relevant candidates and a shortlist could be forming.
The same applies to employers.
Waiting until someone resigns before thinking about where the talent sits can immediately put you into reactive mode.
This is where proactive market mapping becomes incredibly valuable.
Having someone who understands your market proactively identifying relevant businesses, opportunities or individuals can remove a lot of the guesswork and accelerate the process considerably.
3. Knowledge is still power
Technology has transformed recruitment and AI will undoubtedly change it further.
But I still believe there is enormous value in having the right person alongside you who genuinely knows the market.
Someone who understands the companies, the people, the salaries, the talent hotspots and what is actually happening beneath the surface.
Just as importantly, find someone you trust and who is aligned with your personality and approach.
Recruitment remains a very human business.
Working with a large corporate recruiter can absolutely have its advantages, but your experience can ultimately depend upon the individual consultant handling your requirement or career.
Are you working with someone relatively new to the profession or someone who has spent 20+ years mapping the market, recruiting through multiple economic cycles and advising people through significant career decisions?
The name above the door matters.
The person sitting across the table matters more.
4. Candidates should look for the journey, not simply the job
One piece of advice I have given candidates consistently over the years is to look beyond the job description.
Ask yourself:
What is this business actually going through?
Growth, acquisition, private equity investment, consolidation, international expansion, a new ERP system, transformation or restructuring can all create opportunities to develop experience well beyond the basic remit of a finance role.
There is potentially far more career value in joining a business where finance is helping shape the journey than simply moving somewhere that needs another accountant to produce the statutory numbers.
Understand the story behind the vacancy.
That story could ultimately be more important to your career than the job title.
5. Clients should recruit people who can demonstrate impact
When recruiting into accounting and finance, technical capability obviously matters.
But I would increasingly look for evidence of what somebody has actually changed, improved or delivered.
What did they inherit?
What did they do?
What was different afterwards?
The strongest candidates can normally demonstrate this clearly.
They aren’t simply looking for another job. They can explain specifically why their experience is relevant to your requirement and what they could potentially bring to the business.
For employers, getting this right should significantly improve the quality of a shortlist.
6. Your CV is still one of your biggest door openers
For all the changes we have seen in recruitment, the CV remains incredibly important.
Before the interview, the CV has one fundamental job:
Convert interest into a conversation.
Take the time to make it impactful.
One approach I particularly like is looking for evidence around three simple measures:
Time. Money. Percentage.
What did you accelerate?
What did you save, generate, manage or influence financially?
What measurable improvement did you deliver?
Rather than filling every role with a long list of responsibilities, use different positions to demonstrate different dimensions of your experience.
One role might showcase technical accounting capability.
Another might demonstrate leadership and team management.
Another might highlight commerciality, business partnering, transformation or systems implementation.
Collectively, your CV should tell the story of how you have developed.
Keep the structure simple. Include a strong summary at the beginning. Make professional qualifications immediately visible. Clearly identify the company, sector, position and dates.
And finally, interests are only a small part of a CV, but don’t feel the need to make them deliberately quirky simply to stand out.
Specific and genuine is much better.
If you say something is an interest, make sure you can comfortably talk about it when somebody asks.
Perhaps the biggest lesson?
After two decades in recruitment, I still think successful recruitment comes back to a relatively simple combination:
Timing. Knowledge. Preparation. Relationships.
For candidates, understand where the market is going rather than simply where the vacancies are today.
For clients, understand where the talent sits before you desperately need it.
And for both, find somebody who understands your market, understands what you’re trying to achieve and is prepared to be proactive rather than simply waiting for something to happen.
Recruitment will continue to evolve.
Technology will change.
Markets will rise, fall and recover.
But ultimately, putting the right person into the right business at the right point in both of their journeys remains what good recruitment is all about.